top of page

The Gravy Boat Problem: How to Divide Sentimental Items in a Separation of Assets Agreement

5 days ago
7 min read
Hands sorting family keepsakes and holiday ornaments into boxes while dividing sentimental items in a separation of assets agreement

When people think about separation, they usually think about the house, the savings and the pensions. Those are big decisions, and they deserve your attention.


But ask anyone who's been through it, and many will tell you the argument that got heated wasn't about the mortgage. It was about Grandma's gravy boat, the box of baby photos, or who keeps the Christmas ornaments the kids made in Grade 2.


If you're facing this, you're not being petty. These items carry memory, and memory is hard to split down the middle. Here's how to approach sentimental items calmly, and how to make sure what you decide ends up in your separation of assets agreement.


Why Sentimental Items Cause Such Outsized Conflict


A set of dishes may be worth very little on paper. To you, it might be every Sunday dinner you've ever hosted. That gap between dollar value and emotional value is exactly why these items cause so much friction.


A few things are usually going on underneath:

  • They're tied to identity. Family recipes, heirlooms and traditions feel like part of who you are, not just things you own.

  • They're often irreplaceable. You can buy a new sofa. You can't buy your late mother's handwritten recipe cards.

  • They stand in for bigger feelings. Sometimes the argument over the ornaments is really about grief, fairness or feeling unheard.

  • Nobody planned for them. Most couples never talked about who gets what, because they never expected to need to.

  • They're tied to your children. When kids are involved, every object can feel like it carries a piece of their childhood.


Knowing this can take some of the heat out. When a disagreement over a keepsake feels bigger than it should, it usually is about more than the object. Naming that, to yourself or out loud, can make the conversation easier to start.


How Sentimental Items Fit Into Ontario Separation Law

In Ontario, the financial side of separation is built around fairness. Household contents are generally treated as property, but most sentimental items are worth far less in dollars than they are to you emotionally.


That's actually helpful. Because many keepsakes carry modest financial value, they can often be traded and negotiated in practical ways without upsetting the bigger property settlement.


There are a few situations where it's worth taking extra care:

  • Items with real financial value. Jewellery, art, antiques and collections may need to be listed and valued as part of your financial disclosure.

  • Gifts and inheritances. Items that came to one spouse as a gift or inheritance from a third party may be treated differently under Ontario's family property rules.

  • Items you're unsure about. If you can't tell which category something falls into, that's a good question for your lawyer during Independent Legal Advice (ILA).


This post is general information, not legal advice. A mediator can help you talk through the options, but a lawyer is the right person to tell you how the law applies to your specific situation.


Step 1: List the Items Together


Before anyone argues, get everything out in the open. A list takes the emotion down a notch because it turns a vague worry into something you can both look at.


You don't need to list every teaspoon. Start with categories, then add the specific items that matter within each one:

  • Photos, albums, videos and digital files

  • Heirlooms and items from either side of the family

  • Holiday decorations and ornaments

  • Kitchen items, recipes and cookbooks

  • Jewellery and personal keepsakes

  • Children's items, artwork and school memories

  • Furniture, art and décor

  • Items connected to hobbies or family traditions


A few tips make this go more smoothly. Each of you can make your own list first, then compare. Walking through the home room by room helps you remember things you'd otherwise forget. And if the two of you can't be in the house together right now, photos and a shared document work just fine.


The goal at this stage isn't to decide anything. It's simply to make sure nothing important surprises either of you later.


Step 2: Flag Your "Must-Haves"


Once you have a list, each of you privately picks the handful of items that matter most. Keep it short. If everything is a must-have, nothing is, and the conversation gets harder instead of easier.


It can help to ask yourself a few honest questions:

  • Would I truly miss this, or do I just feel I should keep it?

  • Does this connect to my own family history?

  • Is this about the object, or about what it represents?

  • Would a copy, a photo or a smaller piece of it be enough?


Then share your must-haves with each other. Many couples are surprised to find there's less overlap than they feared. Something one person guards fiercely may be something the other hadn't thought twice about.


Where you both flag the same item, don't panic. That's normal, and it's exactly what the next step is for. Try to explain why the item matters to you rather than why you deserve it. "That was my grandmother's, and I remember her using it every Christmas" tends to open a conversation. "I want it and you can't have it" tends to close one.


Step 3: Trade Across Categories


This is where the practical solutions happen. Instead of splitting every item down the middle, look at the whole picture and trade across categories.


For example:

  • One of you keeps the family china from your side, and the other keeps the holiday decorations.

  • One keeps the original photo albums, and the other keeps the digital copies.

  • One keeps the heirloom jewellery from their own family, and the other keeps the sentimental furniture.


Some items can't be divided, but their meaning can be shared. Photos can be scanned. Recipes can be copied. Children's artwork can be photographed or rotated between homes.


It also helps to think about who the item has the deepest connection to. An heirloom from your side of the family often means more to you than to your spouse, and vice versa. Many people find that when each person keeps what comes from their own family, most of the list resolves itself.


Where there's a genuine tie, you have options: one person holds the item for now and agrees it will pass to the children later, you alternate who has it, or you agree on a fair swap for something else of equal importance. A "both of us get something" outcome is often more achievable than people expect


Step 4: Plan for the Holidays


Holiday items are some of the most emotionally charged because they connect directly to family traditions, and the season is closer than it feels. Settling these questions early can take a lot of pressure off an already tender time of year.


If you have children, think about what will help them feel continuity.


  • Ornaments. Decide who keeps the shared collection, or divide it so each child's ornaments travel with them to both homes. Some families let each parent keep half. Others take photos of favourites or buy a few new matching ones so both homes feel familiar.

  • Family recipes. Copy them. A recipe can belong to both of you, and to your children, without anyone giving anything up. Handwritten cards can be scanned or photographed, and you might even cook a favourite dish together with the kids so the tradition keeps going.

  • Heirlooms. If an item has meaning for the children, agree on who holds it for now and whether it will pass to them later. Write that down so it doesn't get lost.

  • Traditions. Talk about which traditions will continue in both homes and which might change. Who hosts, who has the children on which day and what happens with extended family are all worth discussing. A new tradition in each household isn't a loss. For many children, it's something to look forward to.


If you're in the middle of separating right now, you don't have to solve every holiday question at once. Even agreeing on this year's plan, and revisiting it later, can bring real relief.


Step 5: Record It in Your Separation of Assets Agreement


Once you've reached decisions, write them down. A verbal agreement made in a gentle moment can feel very different six months later, especially when memories fade or circumstances change.


In Ontario, this is usually done through a separation agreement. It can document:

  • Who keeps which items

  • How shared or copied items will be handled

  • What happens to items intended for the children

  • How you'll handle a disagreement if one comes up later


Even a simple schedule listing the key sentimental items can prevent misunderstandings down the road. You don't need legal language for every teacup. You need enough clarity that both of you know what was agreed.


At Divorce Is Simple, the separation agreement is prepared based on the decisions you reach in mediation. Before anyone signs, each spouse receives Independent Legal Advice from a separate lawyer, so you both understand what you're agreeing to and the agreement is properly finalized.


When Emotions Run High, Mediation Can Help


Sometimes you can't get through the list without it turning into an argument. That's common, and it doesn't mean you can't reach an agreement.


In mediation, a neutral mediator keeps the conversation structured and productive. The mediator doesn't take sides or make decisions for you. Instead, the mediator helps you understand each other's priorities, identify where you already agree and work through the rest, one decision at a time.


Mediation can help with sentimental items because:

  • It's private and confidential, so personal family matters stay outside the courtroom.

  • You stay in control of the decisions rather than leaving them to someone else.

  • The pace is yours, so difficult topics don't have to be rushed.

  • Sentimental items can be discussed alongside parenting, finances and property, so the whole picture fits together.


You don't need to agree on everything before you begin. Working through the disagreement is what mediation is for.


Conclusion


Sentimental items are rarely about money, which is why they can be so hard to talk about. A simple process makes it manageable: list the items, flag your must-haves, trade across categories, plan for the holidays and put your decisions in writing in your separation of assets agreement.


Take one step at a time

You don't need to have it all figured out before you start. Taking it one step at a time is usually enough, and you don't have to do it alone. Even the most emotional decisions can be resolved respectfully. Book a consultation to see how mediation helps you reach fair agreements.

Parent and child hanging an ornament on a small holiday tree in a warm living room

bottom of page